Everything You Wanted to Know About Hope Not Hate* (*But Were Afraid To Ask)
Hope Not Hate, an organisation which continuously flirts with criminality with apparent CPS immunity. It continues the work of its disgraced predecessor, Searchlight. Scrutiny of this organisation reveals exploitation of English law to further the ambitions of the Labour Party.
On 20 July 2026, Andy Burnham entered Downing Street as Prime Minister with two Hope Not Hate ("HNH") figures already placed near the centre of his operation. Four days earlier, PoliticsHome reported that Alison Phillips was directing his transition and Matthew McGregor would become head of political strategy. Companies House records Phillips as a director of HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED from 24 March 2025 until 16 July 2026; McGregor had run HNH’s campaigns and communications, sat on its board until April 2022 and later moved through 38 Degrees to No 10. Guido Fawkes drew attention to the connection, while the official biographies preferred Barack Obama and the usual campaign-trail glamour. Many readers will be familiar with the sinister tactics of this organisation; others, however, will only know what Wikipedia has to say about it.
In The Tailor of Panama, Harry Pendel, a fraudster tailor played by Geoffrey Rush, invents the “Silent Opposition” for Andy Osnard, an MI6 officer who knows perfectly well that the story is an absurd fabrication. Pendel needs money, Osnard needs useful intelligence; their reports grow more alarming until governments prepare to act. Both retain the consoling belief that Panama contains genuine villains and their dishonesty is therefore public-spirited. “The ends justify the means”, or more accurately, the justification for the means is invented along the way. The US Justice Department’s June 2026 indictment accuses the Southern Poverty Law Center of using $4.1 million in donor funds to pay informants whose work included recruiting for extremist groups and promoting their activities online. The prosecution describes Pendel’s bargain in practice: a watchdog financing the danger upon which its own importance depended.

Searchlight and HNH occupy the same British ground. Both have on occasion exposed real fascists, violent organisers and, more rarely, Islamist networks, but an organisation whose importance and fundraising depend upon finding emergencies has an obvious interest in never running out of them. The editor needs a villain, the politician needs useful intelligence and the pleasantly named Hope Not Hate campaign needs a reason to exist; exaggeration or fabrication may then be excused by the wickedness of the target.
Opposition to fascism cannot make a false allegation true, turn a private writer’s name into public property, cure an unlawful method of gathering data or relieve a political campaigner of the ordinary duty to prove what he publishes. The end and the means remain separate questions, although HNH’s history often treats its stated end – rooting out fascists – as an answer to both. Its modern form begins in Gerry Gable’s Searchlight files.
From Searchlight to HNH
Gerry Gable’s obituary in The Guardian records his journey through the Young Communist League, the Communist Party and the 62 Group. In 1963 he entered David Irving’s flat dressed as a telephone engineer and was convicted for doing so. Searchlight appeared briefly as a newspaper in that decade and returned in 1975, depending upon informants, infiltration and political files which few people outside the organisation could inspect.
Searchlight developed its method against organisations which were often violent; its operatives penetrated, mapped and disrupted them with help that sometimes came from police or security contacts. The same arrangement placed unusual power in a private organisation which gathered political intelligence, decided what it meant and handed the result to people with powers it did not possess.
Column 88 will not yield the tidy verdict favoured by either side. Emma Schubart argued in a September 2025 thread and later UnHerd article that Searchlight relied heavily upon Dave Roberts, an informant with state connections, while later accounts left open whether the supposed paramilitary group had been discovered, infiltrated, exaggerated, used as a honeytrap or all four at different times.
The easy charge that Gable simply invented Column 88 will not survive the record, but the equally neat story of a stable paramilitary organisation observed from a distance is no more convincing. Searchlight’s authority rested upon opaque relations with police, informants and militant networks; infiltration, exaggeration and state manipulation became impossible for an outsider to separate, while the settled legend served the reputation and fundraising of the organisation which repeated it.
The BBC learnt the price of getting it wrong when Panorama broadcast allegations about extremist associations around Conservative politicians in Maggie’s Militant Tendency, then withdrew them and paid substantial damages and costs. The Guardian later reviewed the affair, while Searchlight published its own defence. Private Eye also paid damages after falsely alleging that a military policeman had plotted to abduct and kill Gable; valuable intelligence and reckless allegation could emerge from the same culture, and a person defamed in the process faced an expensive route back.

Parliament had already seen the collateral damage by 1996, when MPs debating the Defamation Bill described small bookshops exposed to proceedings merely because they stocked Searchlight material, meaning that the people who distributed the accusation could be ruined alongside its author. The account appears in the Hansard record.
Searchlight Information Services was incorporated in 1986, and Searchlight Educational Trust followed in 1992. A 2004 New Philanthropy Capital report described the information company as supplying material to police, local authorities and the media, placing Searchlight in the peculiar ground between political campaigning, private intelligence and institutional consultancy long before the HNH name became familiar.
By 1999, Nick Lowles had become co-editor with Steve Silver and increasingly applied Searchlight’s files to electoral campaigning against the BNP. Parts of the radical left remained openly hostile; the surviving Red Action material shows anti-fascists who thought Searchlight too close to police and rather too pleased with its secret information.
Stop the BNP supplied the electoral bridge to Hope not Hate, and the later Nominet record confirms that campaign domains and institutional assets became part of the eventual dispute. Dan Hodges, once described as a communications adviser, later said that the campaign used “every dirty, underhand, low down, unscrupulous trick in the book”.
The split which created HNH
By the late 2000s, Hope not Hate had ceased to be merely a Searchlight slogan and had become its election-facing public brand. HNH’s own archive traces the name to 2003, while Lowles’s Fear and HOPE report says he ran the campaign from 2004 to 2010. Research once printed in a monthly magazine could now be converted into local newspapers, canvassing data and organised election days.
The quarrel between Gable and Lowles became public in 2011. Workers’ Liberty reported the split, while The Jewish Chronicle described an increasingly bitter dispute over direction and control. Gable kept Searchlight magazine; Lowles took the Hope not Hate campaign and, after an unusually brisk week at Companies House, much of the corporate apparatus beneath it.
Companies House records Gerry Gable’s resignation as a director of Searchlight Information Services on 4 December 2011, alongside Sonia Gable’s departure as secretary. Ruth Smeeth became secretary and Simon Tuttle a director on the same date. The paperwork records a transfer of corporate control beneath the public quarrel.
A short-lived HOPE NOT HATE LTD, company number 07719229, had been incorporated in July 2011 and later became HOPE NOT HATE (SERVICES) LIMITED before its dissolution in 2013. A second vehicle, HOPE NOT HATE (LBG) LIMITED, company number 08188502, was incorporated in August 2012 and became the present HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED that October.
On 25 October 2012, Searchlight Information Services became HOPE NOT HATE (1986) LIMITED, while Searchlight Educational Trust became HOPE NOT HATE EDUCATIONAL LIMITED. The 1986 company later became dormant and was voluntarily struck off in July 2015.
The quarrel reached Nominet’s domain-name dispute service, whose record identifies Searchlight Information Services Ltd v Gerry Gable, DRS 11785, as decided on 10 January 2013. The dispute concerned the campaign domains hopenothate.org.uk, hopenothate.co.uk and stopthebnp.org.uk. Corporate control had already changed; the split had become a fight over the campaign’s digital identity.
Public reconciliation came only at an anti-fascist event in 2023, after what The Guardian described as a bitter parting. Searchlight magazine continued separately, while HNH inherited the campaign, information infrastructure, people and habits; it cannot claim the victories while treating the failures as somebody else’s history.
Pulling down the corporate veil

The present arrangement is simple enough once the company numbers are written down. HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED, number 08188502, undertakes the campaigning, research and advocacy for which the name is known. HOPE UNLIMITED CHARITABLE TRUST, charity number 1013880 and company number 02738367, began life as Searchlight Educational Trust, later became HOPE NOT HATE CHARITABLE TRUST and adopted its current name in October 2025.
A charity may lawfully work with a connected non-charity, provided its trustees retain control of charitable money, keep it from party-political purposes and tell donors plainly what is being done. Two registrations answer very little; the useful questions are who controls the work, who pays for it and whether the money remains confined to charitable purposes.
HNH used the same public name across both bodies for years. Staff, websites, appeals and reports appeared beneath one brand, while MPs and newspapers routinely called the campaigning company a charity. The confusion was useful, persistent and eventually serious enough to prompt formal regulatory action.
The accounts explain why this was more than a pedant’s objection. For the year ending 31 December 2024, the trust recorded grants totalling £787,858 to HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED, with £697,913 shown as the 2023 comparative, while £48,102 was owed by the company to the charity. The grant paid for policy and engagement work, research, organising, education and training, while the company supplied administration, fundraising, premises and other services back to the charity. The 2024 accounts give the clearest picture of the arrangement.
The paid staff sat in the political body which performed the work, while one public brand gave the operation the saintly appearance of charitable endeavour – saving impoverished bears in darkest Peru, perhaps. An intelligible public account of the two bodies and their grant-making was indispensable; the Charity Commission repeatedly criticised the delay in providing it.

Charlotte Gill did much of the unglamorous work of following the grants. Her May 2024 investigation calculated £141,380 in government grants during 2019 and 2020 and identified Home Office references, Facebook UK and two unnamed family trusts. The Commission’s current financial history independently records £55,980 of government-grant income in 2020. Paul Hamlyn Foundation’s published data now records six awards to the charity totalling £606,500 between December 2015 and December 2025.
When Gill returned to the structure in April 2025, she asked how a charitable body could finance a connected company campaigning against Reform and Conservative candidates. Her separate Unbound Philanthropy investigation reported £870,000 in grants between 2012 and 2018; the funder’s currently published data independently identifies a £120,000 award in July 2018. Taxpayers and donors are entitled to know which body received the money, what work it purchased and how charitable funding was kept separate from election campaigning. The grant totals alone do not establish diversion to prohibited activity.
The older funding trail reaches beyond the trusts already named. Open Society Foundations says its Fund to Counter Xenophobia supported HNH’s 2012 report on the international “counter-jihad” movement, while its 2014 European register records a $7,118 award to HOPE NOT HATE EDUCATIONAL LTD for Spreading the message of Hope in the Mirror. Network for Social Change recorded £4,996 for the Hope Not Hate campaign in 2010 and £10,000 for HNH Educational’s Together Programme in 2014, and lists the trust again among its 2025–26 Pools grants, ordinarily worth £8,000 to £25,000.
Though smaller than the charity’s later transfers, these grants show HNH’s longstanding dependence on philanthropic funding. Reports and campaigns produced within this network then enter Parliament and the press as independent expertise.
The Bankman-Fried allegation leads into Labour’s funding network. Bankman-Fried was convicted on seven federal counts in November 2023 and sentenced to 25 years in March 2024. A reported £500,000 gift went to David Lawrence, the former Labour candidate and think-tank founder, who acknowledged receiving it but denied using it to fund Labour for the Long Term. That organisation separately donated £30,000 and £7,500 to Wes Streeting in August 2022 and August 2023. The thread identifies the recipient with HNH’s researcher through an unclaimed byline-aggregation page. His professional biography supplies no such identification, and the thread supplies no payment trail to HNH.
The ends justify the means
HNH intervenes in elections, gathers private intelligence, uses assumed identities, supplies ideological case files to sympathetic media and identifies pseudonymous speakers so that employers, platforms, regulators and police may act upon a legal name. Its subjects range from violent neo-Nazis to comedians, writers, councillors, filmmakers and anonymous users whose speech was lawful; Britain’s constrictive speech regime then converts an activist accusation into an employment case, professional complaint or police record without a court ever testing the original claim, as I argued in my earlier article on doxxing.
HNH’s first service to Labour is legislative, manufacturing political problems by selecting, enlarging and classifying material until tighter controls on speech or association appear unavoidable, usually while preserving latitude for favoured and allied ideological groups. HNH supplies the justification and Labour politicians or government institutions press for the restriction; its contribution to the Online Safety Act and the evidence it presented during the Bill’s passage offer a recent example.
Its second service is punitive, using the existing architecture of employment, professional regulation, platform governance and criminal law to incapacitate competent or rising figures to Labour’s right. HNH supplies the name, label and dossier; sympathetic journalists launder the claim into apparent independent fact; employers, parties, platforms, regulators or police then impose the political and economic penalty – often rendering the individual persona non grata in every institution in Britain.
I refer to this initiation and outsourcing of complaints and smear, until a person becomes professionally and politically untouchable, as “The Methodology”. Once the complaint begins in Britain, the process is the punishment; suspension, investigation, disclosure demands, legal expense and permanent search results can destroy a livelihood before the allegation is tested, while exoneration rarely restores what the process has taken.
The accounts below describe intrusive approaches, paid information and coercive pressure, but the operation needs neither a single central order nor an offence by HNH itself. It manufactures the emergency, identifies the target and leaves other institutions to perform the disposal, which they will often do gladly. HNH is the prime mover in what is usually called cancellation.
Douglas Murray used The Spectator to describe HNH’s protection-racket behaviour; The Critic presented HNH under the title “Stop pampering the left’s attack dog”; Novara Media accused it of choosing enemies to fit a preferred narrative; Guido Fawkes pursued the electoral-law consequences of its Labour-facing campaigns. These publications agree on little else, yet each describes a part of the same machine.
The Free Speech Union can defend lawful expression and challenge an employment sanction, but it cannot erase a dossier, compel a friendly newspaper to retract an ideological label or restore a reputation after accusation has hardened into biography. The FSU has itself flagged HNH as a “pro-censorship lobby group” whose funding warrants investigation, alongside the Center for Countering Digital Hate and the Global Disinformation Index, and announced a three-part investigation led by David Rose. HNH remains one of the recurring Stasi-like terrors of British institutional life, chilling speech without ever needing to wield the coercive power itself.
A bankrupt doctrine from the radical Sixties
In Repressive Tolerance Herbert Marcuse argued that movements of the Right should be denied tolerance at the stage of speech and propaganda because post-fascist society remained in permanent danger. The prose is denser than the proposition – if catastrophe is always about to happen, censorship may always be described as prevention, and any means may be excused by the supposed end.
Marcuse need not have been on the HNH office reading list for the family resemblance to be obvious. HNH’s mission statement places investigation, exposure and campaigning side by side; a researcher asks what the evidence supports, while a campaigner asks what will move a newspaper, donor or MP. Combining the jobs gives every alarming interpretation a second use.
In December 2016, after Jo Cox’s murder, The Economist examined HNH’s figures at perhaps the organisation’s high-water mark as a trusted anti-fascist source. It found that the public briefings had exaggerated the apparent celebration of her death and misrepresented HNH’s own data; HNH’s advocacy reading had hardened into media fact before The Economist challenged it.
HNH is less relaxed about other people’s imprecision, and after Nigel Farage alleged in 2016 that it pursued violent and undemocratic means, the organisation threatened defamation proceedings before he withdrew the allegation the following year. The organisation retains first-class lawyers while applying grave political descriptions to people who could not finance a week in the High Court.
In 2019, HNH apologised and paid damages and costs to Sharon Klaff after material associated her with racist and extremist sympathies and a bookshop attack. The reported settlement shows how a political dossier can become a legally actionable falsehood. Under the Defamation Act’s single-publication rule, an unchanged page does not reset limitation, but publication in a materially different manner, including its prominence or reach, may create a fresh claim; a future State of Hate report repeating actionable allegations about several targets could therefore expose HNH to coordinated proceedings.
During the disorder of August 2024, Nick Lowles posted that acid had been thrown at a Muslim woman in Middlesbrough, then apologised when police said a third-party report had produced no corroborating evidence or complaint from a victim. Fast-moving events produce mistakes, but Lowles’s position gave the rumour an authority unavailable to an anonymous account.
The Shawcross review of Prevent criticised counter-extremism work which placed provocative or mainstream right-wing commentary inside an extreme-right account without a meaningful terrorism connection. Once a private political judgement enters safeguarding, the adjective can reappear in an official record as though an independent body had established it.
The New Yorker’s profile of an informant inside National Action described intelligence reaching the authorities through HNH and operatives taking personal risk; HNH’s researchers also examined al-Muhajiroun and produced the Gateway to Terror report. HNH later turned the reputation built around that work against increasingly ordinary opponents; a warning system which attaches the residue of terrorism to comedians, councillors and pseudonymous writers becomes useless when a genuine danger appears.
After Ann Widdecombe’s death, Guido reported that HNH had removed an archived page attacking her in highly pejorative terms, and The Telegraph also covered the deletion. An organisation which keeps permanent biographical files on other people should preserve a visible record of its own amendments and deletions. By the time this page disappeared, Widdecombe was dead and no correction could reach her.
Widdecombe died on 8 July 2026. Joshua Kerry faces murder and terrorism-preparation charges; the prosecution alleges an extreme-left or anti-establishment motivation, and his trial is listed for 8 June 2027.
From Lucy Powell to the Online Safety Act – HNH's institutional functions

Lucy Powell MP, now Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, put a proposal before the Commons in September 2018 which sought to make administrators of large online forums answerable for material posted in private groups. Most examples concerned private Facebook groups, and naturally HNH’s discovery of the Young Right Society supplied the central justification for greater restriction of online speech. HNH identified and classified the problem, Powell converted it into a demand for statutory control and Hansard called HNH “the charity” before Parliament had even mastered the identity of its source.
The desire to restrict speech and association is palpable, and those calling for it have acquired no more sophisticated understanding of the internet in the years since; what little they know comes from the exaggerated hellscape described by HNH. The mechanism resembles the weapons-of-mass-destruction case for the Iraq invasion insofar as selective intelligence supplies a pretext, a subject on which I wrote in 2018.
In State of Hate 2021, Matthew McGregor and Liron Velleman were credited with Denialism Must End. Elsewhere, the report described Eleanor Williams’s false allegations as “trumped-up grooming allegations” and later referred more generally to “so-called ‘grooming’ gangs” when discussing citizen journalists. The National Pulse called this an attempt to downplay the national scandal. HNH placed public anger over organised sexual exploitation inside a wider world of conspiracy, denialism and far-right agitation.
Liron Velleman, now a convicted child sex offender, was listed as HNH’s political organiser and had just been elected as a Labour councillor in Barnet when Parliament heard him on 26 May 2022. The published ward result records 1,625 votes. Parliament invited Velleman, an HNH political employee, to present his employer’s policy as expert evidence on the Online Safety Bill.
In that Hansard evidence, Velleman urged Ofcom to target smaller platforms because right-wing users moved there after bans on larger services, celebrated deplatforming and named Tommy Robinson, Urban Scoop and citizen journalists filming migrants at the border as people who should not return through a journalistic exemption. Velleman treated protections for journalistic and democratically important content as loopholes through which HNH’s opponents might escape a ban.
At the same hearing, Velleman defended pseudonymity for LGBT people and domestic-abuse survivors who might verify privately while withholding a public legal name. The hearing shows why HNH and legislation such as the Online Safety Act are not your friends – they routinely advocate further suppression of speech in these deliberately asymmetric ways.
Between 3 and 10 December 2024, while still a Labour councillor, Velleman sent explicit material to an undercover officer whom he believed to be a 13-year-old girl, asked whether she was “at home alone”, demanded “show me your bra” and asked whether she was a virgin. He pleaded guilty to attempting sexual communication with a child and attempting to cause a child aged 13 to 15 to view an image of sexual activity. On 20 March 2026, Southwark Crown Court imposed eight months’ imprisonment suspended for 15 months, ten years on the sex offenders register, restrictions on unsupervised contact with children and 180 hours of unpaid work. Jewish News reported the messages in detail, and the BBC’s report also covered the conviction and sentence.
Parliament received Velleman as a moral authority on online harm because HNH’s name supplied the credibility. The National Pulse gave the year of his oral evidence as 2023, while Hansard records 26 May 2022, but the more serious failure was contemporary – Parliament heard demands to weaken journalistic and political safeguards from an HNH organiser whose employer had a direct interest in deplatforming the people named.
Nadine Dorries, who introduced the Online Safety Bill as Conservative Culture Secretary, now argues that the resulting Online Safety Act should be repealed. The company manufactures the harm and the parliamentary Labour Party presses for the censorial solution, although a risk-averse Conservative government proved equally receptive and enacted it.

Joe Mulhall’s enthusiasm for the regime which became the Online Safety Act is explicit in his evidence to the Petitions Committee on 2 November 2021. He argued that effective legislation would have to reach beyond illegal content, pressed for legal consequences for platform executives and worried that protections for journalistic and political speech would undermine years of work persuading companies to ban HNH’s targets. HNH need only provide the label and the name, because Britain already has the police, regulator, employer and platform required to make the consequence real.
The censorship consortium
HNH belongs to a network of organisations campaigning for digital censorship, which often make joint interventions to lend authority to their demands. HNH told Parliament that in 2021 it had led a coalition with Reset, the Antisemitism Policy Trust, IMPRESS, Glitch, Clean Up the Internet, Demos and Catch22 which fought to retain duties concerning material that was legal but considered harmful. Once lawful expression is recast as harm, the activist who supplied the category becomes indispensable to the regulator charged with suppressing it – this is where HNH hoped to position itself.
Luminate and the Sandler Foundation incubated Reset in 2020; Luminate housed the organisation until 1 January 2024 while continuing to fund and collaborate with it afterwards. Luminate says Reset supported passage of the EU Digital Services Act and the British Online Safety Act. Luminate was established by Pierre and Pam Omidyar and financed through the Pierre M. Omidyar Trust, so private philanthropy helped build a body which then organised pressure for public censorship law.
An archived 2019 biography placed Simon Clark in the chair of Foreign Policy for America and on the board of HNH USA; Companies House records his appointment to the British Center for Countering Digital Hate board in May 2020, FP4A announced his replacement that December, and American returns identify him as CCDH chair from 2021 to 2024. Jemma Levene supplies the second personnel bridge, having moved from HNH’s deputy directorship to become CCDH’s chief operating officer.
Reset’s 2024 US return records a $100,000 grant to CCDH, adding money to the personnel connection, while in 2019 the government’s Commission for Countering Extremism published research by HNH senior researcher Joe Mulhall. Funders incubate specialist campaigners, those campaigners lobby for controls and supply expert evidence, and government then republishes their analysis as part of the official debate.
A polite knock at the door – deception and HNH/Searchlight
Searchlight relied upon informants and entry by pretence; HNH has entered closed online groups, used assumed identities and sent researchers to people who did not know whom they were really meeting.
Harry Shukman supplied the most complete modern example while working as Christopher Morton, an episode later described in Year of the Rat under his usual name. Critics called the passport a forgery, but HNH’s lawyers intimated defamation proceedings, forcing The Spectator to withdraw the claim and placing others who had repeated it under the same pressure. John Power yielded on the document but he did not yield on the conduct itself – “the clarification did reveal that Shukman used the deed poll process to obtain a second identity for the purpose of deception.”

English law gives an adult wide freedom to assume a new name. GOV.UK’s sample deed-poll wording says the old name has been given up and the new one adopted “for all purposes”. HM Passport Office policy requires one name for official purposes, partly to prevent crime and evasion of detection; Home Office guidance also recognises professional and stage names. Parliament stated in 2023 that a deceptive or fraudulent change may be prosecuted as part of the underlying fraud or deception. Rayden, Tayntons, Hegarty and Clarkson Wright & Jakes state the same ordinary boundary – a name may be freely chosen, but not to deceive, defraud or obtain criminal benefit.
Christopher Morton was not, on Power’s account, an identity adopted for all purposes. Shukman continued to publish under his usual name, retained his ordinary email address, used the Morton identity to gain the confidence of targets and changed back when the operation ended. His lawyers said he had fully adopted the new name and that the old bylines were an oversight. The passport was genuine, but the sequence reveals a temporary investigative persona equipped with state-backed identification.
Activist investigators possess no general statutory licence, so ordinary law applies. Section 170 of the Data Protection Act 2018 can criminalise knowingly or recklessly obtaining, disclosing or retaining personal data without the data controller’s consent, subject to statutory defences including public interest; the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 can apply to a course of conduct which the person knows or ought to know amounts to harassment; section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006 may apply to a dishonest false representation made with the required intent to gain or cause loss in money or property; and trespass accompanied by conduct intended to intimidate people away from lawful activity, or to obstruct or disrupt it, may engage aggravated trespass.
A false dossier causing serious reputational harm may be answered under the Defamation Act 2013 unless truth, honest opinion or the public-interest defence succeeds. This is a poor practical safeguard for an ordinary target, because proceedings are costly, limitation is short and the publisher may hold the very evidence needed to test its defence.
Blackmail under section 21 of the Theft Act 1968 has exact requirements – an unwarranted demand with menaces, made with a view to gain or intent to cause loss in money or property.
Hope Not Hate and "The Methodology"
“Doxxing”, or digital murder, is the malicious sharing or reconstruction of private identifying information in order to breach the boundary between the digital, professional and physical worlds and harm the doxxee maximally. The broader usage adopted in my earlier Reiners.org.uk essay includes jigsaw identification and disclosure of the legal name behind a pen name or anonymous account. Political pseudonyms long predate the internet; the American founders used them, and Robert Fritsche has compared that tradition with modern digital anonymity. Doxxing is how professional activists and malcontents outsource harm to the mob and to institutions.
X’s March 2024 policy defines doxxing as sharing somebody’s private information without permission, recognises that the identity of an anonymous user may itself be private information and says abusive intent should inform enforcement. Abusive intent is one enforcement factor, alongside the nature of the information and whether it is already public; an accompanying accusation or invitation to contact, punish or menace the person identified can supply evidence of that intent.
The Methodology is childishly simple. HNH puts a legal name in the headline, adds photographs, an employer or locality and encloses the person within an ideological case file which can be sent to a newsroom, employer or regulator in seconds. The squeamishness and cowardice of the median British citizen is weaponised, and our legal landscape permits it; the targets differ in conduct and public role, but the object remains the same – connect opinion to the legal person and let respectable institutions do the rest.
HNH’s 2021 Patriotic Alternative report named Gareth Stone as the broadcaster Horus and described his work as a marketing executive. The profile combined that identification with an account of his videos, political affiliations and Telegram audience.
In October 2021, HNH published private Telegram messages attributed to Conservative councillor Tim Wills concerning Patriotic Alternative. The party suspended him pending investigation; Lowles also demanded expulsion and removal of the whip. Wills resigned his Worthing council seat on 15 October while the council’s code-of-conduct investigation remained open. Labour councillor Dawn Smith later described demonstrations demanding his departure, attended by Labour councillors. Her account records the mobilisation around the published allegations as well as the subsequent Labour by-election victory.
HNH published its account of Conservative councillor Andy Weatherhead’s earlier New British Union involvement on 15 November 2022. Six days later, ITV reported his resignation from Kent County Council and Dymchurch Parish Council following suspension. Conservative association chairman Stephen James expressly thanked HNH for bringing the information through the party’s official complaints procedure “so that I could act”. HNH had delivered the material directly into the disciplinary process.
In July 2023, HNH named Paul Gilbert as the PatriArt, publishing his occupation and locality alongside his political associations. The name was the headline; a web designer’s working life became part of the dossier.
The December 2023 report revisited HNH’s 2019 identification of Royal Navy employees Kenny McCourt and Mike Lynton. HNH recorded that neither had been disciplined at that stage. It then credited renewed exposure of McCourt’s Patriotic Alternative role in 2022 with his dismissal from the Navy. Its profile of Lynton, whom it identified as the writer Mike Kernow, discussed his employment without reporting a dismissal.
On 25 March 2024, HNH attributed the anonymous Telegram account Neo Glave to the comedian Leo Kearse. Chortle reported on 9 April that his regular GB News appearances had stopped after the allegation and that he had returned to Headliners the previous evening, after two weeks away.
Christopher Lee Matthews, known online as ST Audits, became the subject of a May 2024 HNH article identifying the man behind the channel and discussing his wrestling history; later reporting corroborated that identity and background. His wrestling history became part of HNH’s political case against him.
On 20 June 2024, Gregory Davis published Egg-sposed, naming Charles Cornish-Dale as Raw Egg Nationalist. HNH described matching photographs, a newspaper visible in a background and a partly redacted text exchange to identify him; it also said photographs had confirmed his location. Its stated reason for naming him was his reach and what it characterised as increasingly extreme rhetoric. The article expressly objected to his avoiding “scrutiny and social consequences”. Disclosure of the identity was the chosen intervention, and consequences were part of HNH’s own justification.
In his subsequent account, Cornish-Dale disputed HNH’s explanation and suspected it concealed another source. He also reproduced an earlier approach by a Business Insider journalist to a farm shop, asking for help identifying him.
In November 2024, HNH named Aidan Heaps and Toby Chapman as the masked figures behind Whites Against Replacement. It paired the identification with an account of their posts and a warning that police should watch them closely.
On 3 March 2025, HNH named Sam Wilkes as Zoomer Historian, publishing the identification under the bylines of David Lawrence and Gregory Davis. Davis also publicly credited Lawrence and himself with the work. In these articles, the legal name is prominently presented as the discovery for which the investigators claim credit.
The 19 May 2025 article identifying Michael Wright as Morgoth carried the names of Harry Shukman, Gregory Davis, Patrik Hermansson and David Lawrence. HNH said its undercover reporter had met Wright at the Scyldings conference in August 2023; the article’s photograph was credited to that reporter. It also published recollections from former neighbours and said Wright had been contacted for comment.
In his response of 25 May, Wright alleged further conduct: questions to the tenant of his former home, who he said called the police; a return visit by Shukman with an offer of payment for letters or documents bearing his name, and door-to-door approaches by Shukman and Hermansson. He also said the conference photograph was taken without consent in breach of the event’s rules.
HNH used the disclosure that same day in a fundraising email, asking for £10, £20 or another sum for further investigations. Anonymity had been stripped away; the exposure now supplied the next appeal for money.
The public-interest case ranges from a councillor concealing a material political association to a private writer using a pen name, while a credible threat of violence bears no resemblance to historical revisionism, offensive jokes or an unpopular view on migration. HNH nevertheless publishes no intelligible threshold for naming a pseudonymous speaker, buying information, approaching neighbours, retaining private data or correcting a mistake.
My earlier doxxing essay recorded a six-day suspension of HNH’s X account after the Raw Egg Nationalist disclosure. The essay first appeared in The Critic in 2024 and was later expanded for Reiners.org.uk. A temporary platform sanction could not restore the anonymity already lost.
In his April 2026 account of being doxxed, HowlingMutant described an approach to a former girlfriend through her workplace, seeking damaging material about him. That same month, reporting on threats against Chibi Reviews reproduced a post showing a man with a shovel beside his deceased brother’s grave. Some disclosures impart no public insight and use private information only to inconvenience, frighten or expose a person to the mob; intent is not difficult to infer in such cases.
There is one aspect of the methodology which is seldom discussed. Doxxing, and the passing of damaging claims to HNH, often flows from ones political opponents, or indeed, is simply instigated by HNH themselves. That said, in an increasingly fractuous British right wing, these complaints can often be a product of intra-right conflict. In this sense, HNH have positioned themselves as the grievance and body for hard right individuals reporting other hard right individuals in an attempt at one-upmanship.
The people behind the dossiers
In my view, HNH launders hysteria into law reform and smear, with professional credentials supplying the authority its accusations require.
Nick Lowles, founder and chief executive, circulated an unsubstantiated acid-attack report during the August 2024 disorder. Cleveland Police investigated a third-party report, found nothing, received no victim’s complaint or medical notification, and closed the log pending further information; Lowles apologised.

The institutional record includes the Sharon Klaff libel settlement: HNH admitted falsely associating her with the Bookmarks attackers and suggesting film placed her there. She was absent; no film of her participation existed. HNH called it an honest mistake, said it corrected and apologised that day, and agreed damages. The accusation had nevertheless appeared with an assurance of evidence which did not exist - often the case for HNH - whose veneer of academic and journalistic grounding is wafer thin.
Joe Mulhall, 'research director', supplies academic veneer. His doctorate came from Royal Holloway, ranked a modest 42nd out of 130 overall in the Complete University Guide 2027, and his writing has fixated on British Fascism After the Holocaust. Before the Petitions Committee in November 2021, he supported online controls extending beyond illegal content to lawful material classified as harmful and the systems amplifying it. The appetite for wider state control over the speech of ordinary Englishmen is recorded in his own parliamentary evidence.

David Lawrence, a 'senior researcher', co-authored the 2021 report doxxing Horus; Gregory Davis also credited Lawrence and himself with doxxing Zoomer Historian in March 2025. Publication of an identity was the advertised achievement. The Law Commission’s 2021 report also cited his co-authored Antisemitism and Misogyny: Overlap and Interplay when considering stirring-up offences, similar to that found in s.19 of the Public Order Act 1986, covering hatred based on sex and transgender status. The Commission expressly excluded merely offensive comments from its proposal. The citation nevertheless shows Lawrence’s work entering an official argument for extending the criminal law of expression beyond even its dour position today.
Gregory Davis, another ‘senior researcher’, was one of the four named authors of HNH’s Morgoth investigation. The accompanying email of 19 May 2025, signed “Gregory”, described its subject as “using anonymity to shield himself from consequences”, then requested £10, £20 or another sum for further investigations. The loss of Morgoth’s anonymity was an accomplishment for which HNH donors were asked to pay; consequences were part of the sales pitch. Davis can be found on Bluesky and X. He has been active in identifying pseudonymous writers and publishing dossiers for years; it is worth checking whether he is following you, dear reader.
Patrik Hermansson, a senior researcher, was Shukman’s handler during his undercover investigation, attested to in Year of the Rat. In his account of being identified, Morgoth alleges that Hermansson and Shukman went door-to-door around his former home, questioning residents about his identity and whereabouts while presenting themselves as journalists.


Harry Shukman, formerly of The Times and Mill Media, says his undercover purposes included disrupting the groups he entered. He also says he sought to avoid provoking remarks his subjects would not ordinarily make, while Edward Dutton’s account says Shukman requested a photograph and then asked about the Holocaust death toll; Dutton interpreted the exchange as an attempt to elicit usable material. Morgoth separately alleges that Shukman offered payment for documents bearing his name.


Matthew Collins, a former far-right activist turned informant, was identified by ITV as HNH’s intelligence chief in its account of Robbie Mullen’s exposure of the plot to murder Rosie Cooper. Collins was portrayed by Stephen Graham in The Walk-In.

Georgie Laming directs campaigns and communications. The documentary’s website credits her with campaigns to remove Andrew Tate from social media and expose Paul Marshall’s online activity; her Vote HOPE appeal sought help opposing Reform. A newsroom presenting this operation’s output as disinterested expertise helps conceal the political campaign it is reporting.

Rosie Carter appeared as HNH’s policy and engagement director at a Birkbeck-hosted event in 2022; researcher Safya Khan-Ruf discussed Patriotic Alternative on ITV in 2023.
The process is the punishment
Doxxing is often dismissed as mere embarrassment for the doxxee, or bad manners by the doxxer, by people who have never looked into the subject, much less been subjected to it. It is closer to digital murder, and can at times carry a life sentence of unemployability – or, in worse situations, a permanent need for security and heightened vigilance against politically motivated attacks. The target’s name becomes connected to a location, family, employer or hostile allegation while reputational damage, threats and physical danger are outsourced to strangers. Britain has no freestanding civil wrong or criminal offence called doxxing, so the victim must piece together a remedy from data protection, misuse of private information, harassment and the law of defamation, while platforms and search engines routinely accept “in the public interest” as a password for leaving scandalising material in circulation.
The target must identify and serve the publisher, bear the litigation risk and then win; the doxxer can trigger consequences at almost no cost. An identified speaker may lose work, face a professional complaint or Prevent referral, attract police attention, lose banking or hosting, and have activists contact relatives while friendly journalists repeat the dossier until allegation resembles fact. The original words need not be unlawful, because an employer need only fear the next headline for punishment to begin.
Anonymity against state fiat
Anonymity and pseudonymity are requirements for legitimately free expression within Britain’s dystopian speech landscape. Anonymous writers deserve our thanks; from @maxtempers to @kunley_drukpa they have advanced the national conversation in Britain at a pace that no amount of Fraser Nelsons or Dan Hodges could ever hope to contain. Pen names do not just allow the fabled Overton window to have its shutters blown off, but perhaps more crucially in a highly censorial society, they protect whistleblowers, dissidents, junior employees and regulated professionals. The American founders used pseudonyms in constitutional argument, as this record of their pseudonyms shows. Scoundrels and conmen use them to vanish and reappear unblemished too; it is not a practice merely reserved for the morally attractive, nor should that be the expectation. HNH delights in this fact, and various members of its staff have licked their lips at the prospect of deanonymizing the internet in Britain to this end. Never again will conversations be had about questions such as immigration.
For the uninitiated, Britain’s speech regime has three tiers. Criminal law sits at the top. Lucy Connolly encountered it after Lord Hermer consented to her prosecution under section 19 of the Public Order Act 1986, while Allison Pearson was visited by Essex police investigating a suspected criminal offence over a tweet; the investigation closed without charge. The second tier consists of regulatory and employment penalties; the third is social cancellation, doxxing, reputational destruction and functional defamation, the trade of HNH and comparable NGOs. At the criminal end Britain is not free. Figures summarised by the House of Lords Library record more than 12,000 arrests by 35 police forces in England and Wales in 2023 under section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 and section 1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1988, covering abusive and menacing communications as well as offensive messages. Arrest, process and publicity punish before a court can inspect the substance.

These tiers await anybody who speaks frankly and with impact about the reality of 2026 Britain, particularly figures treated as a threat to the permanent centrism of the Blairite regime. They stifle the conversations the country most needs, including an earnest discussion of demography; in digital anonymity, ordinary human passions can still play out naturally, and it has become the Englishman’s principal refuge from a social-engineering-prone state.
It took the leveraged buyout of Twitter, now X, by Elon Musk in 2022 to reopen even this narrow space for British expression, and X remains the only large platform which is functionally social in the older sense. Treating some people’s speech as more worthy of freedom than the speech of others created the category of hate speech and began the corrosion in the first place. Connolly’s case states the present iron rule – “It’s not what you say, it’s who you say it as.”
Once HNH publishes a name, and alleges conjunction with far-right, fascist or extreme activity, the target receives none of the safeguards which accompany a criminal or disciplinary charge – no disclosure of the full evidence, its credibility, a neutral tribunal, legal aid or presumption that context will be considered. The publisher controls the initial file, every amendment and the archive; the target carries the economic and psychological cost, with the short limitation period and price of defamation proceedings placing an effective appeal beyond most people.
On 23 May 2018, City A.M. reported that Standard Chartered had dismissed the banker Tom Dupre after receiving an HNH complaint about his leadership of Generation Identity’s UK branch. The bank confirmed that he no longer worked there and declined further comment.
Tom Rowsell, the documentarian behind Survive the Jive, has lived for years beneath an HNH case file. Material supplied to Reiners.org.uk included a 2019 letter of claim disputing allegations that he had links to National Action and attended a training camp, after which HNH amended the wording while leaving the broader file online. Rowsell later said counter-terrorism officers questioned him under Schedule 7 as he returned from a family holiday, and he remains unable to discover where the file travelled or what part it played.
Political theorist Jake Scott was discussed in a 2025 HNH article which relied partly upon messages said to come from a private editorial chat. Before publication he had no useful way to test whether the messages were complete, who supplied them or how they were obtained; afterwards the accusation was public and the cost of disproving it fell upon him.
In The Spectator, Douglas Murray wrote that HNH had indicated it might remove his name from a forthcoming report if he withdrew criticism of the organisation. HNH disputed his wider account, but on Murray’s description the bargain used reputational exposure as leverage against criticism of HNH itself; this sat alongside HNH’s public claim that “Douglas Murray actively inspires hate crimes”, while similar threats have been reported by other subjects of HNH articles. The correspondence should be published, since an organisation which asks the public to trust its reading of other people’s private messages cannot plead delicacy about its own.
The Nursing and Midwifery Council obtained an 18-month interim suspension order on 17 July 2026 against mental-health nurse and Restore candidate Marlon West, in circumstances which he says arose from comments about the grooming of his daughter by Pakistani men. The NMC says it does not act merely because speech causes offence and that the timing was independent of politics. HNH is not identified publicly as the complainant, but the case shows what a regulator can do once a legal name and political dossier are available – restrict a career before any final fitness-to-practise finding.
More people must understand the power of regulators such as the SRA, BSB, GMC, HCPC, NMC and others to censor and financially punish professionals for views expressed under their legal names. In a welcome turn of events, the BSB has now stated it will not be taking third party complaints relating to social media forward as they do not have a "direct interest or standing" – a party complaining must be identified in a social media post by a practitioner – anything less will be treated as "regulatory intelligence" and be recorded against them. While this is a sensible rolling back, which others should follow on, it comes late in the expansion of belief-oriented professional penalty; regulators' interference in the private beliefs and speech of professionals has expanded over the past decade as regulators enlarged the idea of public confidence and reached further into the individual's personal life. Organisations such as HNH make the mission-creep more dangerous by turning lawful political speech into ready-made complaint material which regulators can pore over for years, a process which is slow amid Britain’s extensive regulatory backlogs and already growing due to the post-lockdown uptick in political reporting.
The usual target is an anonymous writer, provincial councillor, junior employee, independent filmmaker or abrasive internet broadcaster – but professionals carry a secondary risk. HNH has staff, donors, legal advice, press relationships and access to officials; the individual has a salary, mortgage, home address and relatives who never volunteered for public life. To describe the result as a free exchange of ideas is rather like describing a kicking someone in the teeth, in steel-capped boots, as a dance because both men moved their feet.
Weaponising the Englishman’s squeamishness
The instinctual squeamishness of the British public is one of its key weaknesses, and HNH’s entire playbook exploits it. Create a smell around somebody, baseless or not, and the British will remember it forever, irrespective of whether it is true.
That reflex now shapes automated hiring and firing, hostile criminal speech law, professional regulation and the whole Westminster press and policy ecosystem. In my own circles, I have watched organisations from Restore and Policy Exchange to Reform UK, New Culture Forum and the Prosperity Institute withdraw from sensible and capable people once HNH had created the smell around them.
It supplies the stink, the political label and a little libel; the employer, regulator, venue or party administers the penalty. Even those who can finance a claim may fear further publicity. In Britain, an accusation need not be true to be effective; it need only arrive beneath the logo of an NGO and feel legitimate to people who have never examined the organisation behind it.
The ideal first response would have been crowd-funded group litigation capable of testing the recurring case files and compelling disclosure, but Britain is a poor country when measured against the cost of enforcing reputation in the High Court and its political sensibilities are worse. Besides the legislative solutions collected at Reiners.org.uk/bills, the cheaper answer is cultural – the Englishman must overcome his natural squeamishness, or perish.
FUD Daily put the fear in deliberately maximal terms, writing that “Hope Not Hate wants you dead for the opinions you hold. They have ways and means of achieving it, and sometimes they succeed.” The line captures the position of a person identified, named as an enemy and left to discover which employer, stranger or official will act next.
My experiences with Hope Not Hate
On 22 June 2025, I published an investigative article looking into HNH's activities titled “How Long Can the CPS Ignore the Criminality of Hope Not Hate?”; the research was carried out with my now-disgraced co-author, Alex Cameron. Cameron appeared in the by-line under the name Coppen, the name used to conceal his identity, age, location and past questionable dealings from me and others who established my now-defunct blog & project, The Restorationist.
The investigative article spread widely through my X account, and within only two weeks I was contacted by HNH researchers through the contact page of my blog. Naturally, they sought to pressure me into removing the article from public view. They did so by threatening to publish articles about me alone, and by attempting to remove me from GB PAC's advisory board. This is precisely the variety of ultimatum given to Douglas Murray, and others who have researched HNH's methods or chosen to speak out regarding its Stasi-like behaviour toward ordinary Englishmen. A day after receiving this message, a dossier of excerpts from my published work in Conservative Home, The Critic, and my own blog, was sent to both an employer and the Bar Standards Board. In response, my inclination was to channel the late President Richard Nixon, and suggest to HNH's researchers that "there could be no negotiation with terrorists".
Despite being named as a co-author on the investigative piece which led to this situation, curiously, Cameron/Coppen was never contacted or threatened by HNH. Later in 2025, he would work to conceal the critique of HNH, first paywalling it, then praising HNH's methods in various published statements, then openly repurposing The Restorationist's website (on which he served as the webmaster) toward defaming me at considerable poetic length.
Fortunately, a 5 July Wayback capture and UK Reloaded’s republication of 8 July preserve the original article, with its original byline. My interview on the findings (with Professor Ed Dutton) is recorded here. Carl Benjamin covered the piece on Akkad Daily, and Conservative Post followed on 7 July, here.
The Charity Commission Cometh
On 7 July 2025, Ben Habib sent a formal letter to the Charity Commission in his capacity as chairman of GBPAC, citing the compilation of findings after I raised the research as a member of the PAC’s advisory board. HNH had recently attacked GBPAC's personnel and advisers in a lengthy article in the summer of 2025. In his letter, Habib asked the regulator to examine charity number 1013880, its financial relationship with HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED, political campaigning, libel, harassment and data handling under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011 and section 75A. The letter was published on X, placing those allegations before the Commission; it was, in my view, a proper response to a political smear by an organisation receiving substantial grants from the connected charity.
The Commission’s chronology began with advice and guidance to trustees in 2024. The regulator says fresh concerns led it to open a further compliance case in July 2025, after which Jack Rankin MP said on 15 September that he had asked “the head of the Charity Commission to open an investigation”. John Power had also been investigating HNH’s use of the passport issued in Shukman’s Christopher Morton identity while infiltrating the Basket Weavers, and Connor Tomlinson wrote on 8 December 2025 that “after a year of investigating, journalist John Power has revealed how Hope Not Hate procured a passport to allow their operative, Harry Shukman, to pose as alias Christopher Charles Morton to the targets of their documentary Undercover – Exposing the Far Right and subsequent smear pieces in the Guardian.”


The Charity Commission said on 22 January 2026 that it had received repeated complaints over several years about whether the company’s activities were connected with or endorsed by the charitable arm, and closed the case only after the charity changed its name, appointed three independent trustees, revised website references, appointed a new charity secretary and proposed management roles for people without existing responsibilities in the company.
The Commission criticised the delay. Its statement confirmed what critics had said for years – the public could not reliably tell where the charity ended and the political company began. The funding relationship survived once the names, personnel and websites were rearranged with greater care, leaving the political network which made the structure useful largely untouched.
Labour’s useful ally
Jody McIntyre’s March 2026 thread follows the paperwork from HNH into Labour’s wider campaign machine. I have checked its names against Companies House, Electoral Commission records and parliamentary registers to present what follows below.
Simon Tuttle served on the board of HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED from September 2012 until 2 September 2026 and made a £10,000 donation to Labour Together in 2018. Anna Turley’s Register of Members’ Financial Interests recorded her service as both company director and charity trustee until July 2024, while Jane Hogarth came from Labour fundraising and joined the HNH board in 2018, as the filing history records.

HNH’s Labour-facing infrastructure also runs through the unions, because it operates a Trade Union Network and in 2024 UNISON said that its Campaign Fund paid for work “fighting racism and targeting the far right via HOPE not hate”.
McIntyre then carries the trail through Ruth Smeeth, Jemma Levene and Jon Cruddas. Companies House sharpens one detail that is missed in his thread, because Smeeth resigned as company secretary on 1 March 2015 and Levene was appointed secretary that same day. Smeeth returned to the board as a director in May, the register now recording her as Baroness Anderson, and resigned on 11 July 2024 when her appointment as a government whip took effect. A US diplomatic cable had already recorded her briefing American officials during the Brown government and speculating upon the Prime Minister’s intentions.
Jemma Levene’s move from HNH to CCDH supplies the personnel bridge described above, while Jon Cruddas joined HNH’s board in March 2025 after a long Labour career. McIntyre places Morgan McSweeney at the centre of the wider Labour Together world of campaign staff, allied NGOs and political appointments.
Alison Phillips bridges this gap. Phillips joined HNH’s board in March 2025 and later that year became chief executive of Labour Together, subsequently rebranded as ThinkLabour; she resigned the HNH directorship when her role in Burnham’s transition became public. Matthew McGregor had already travelled the other route, from HNH’s campaigns and board to 38 Degrees and then No 10 as head of political strategy by summer 2026. HNH campaigns against Labour’s opponents and manufactures political-risk categories; Burnham has recruited the people who know how to use them, chiefly, I suspect, to fight his internal Labour battles in the manner of Alastair Campbell.
Searchlight’s wider circle had already reached coercive state power through Richard Hermer KC, Attorney General from July 2024 to July 2026, whose appointment was celebrated by Searchlight in an article describing him as an “active and dedicated” former volunteer who later gave occasional legal advice and became a patron of Searchlight Research Associates; Searchlight stated it was “proud to count him amongst our friends”. The law officer responsible for consenting to sensitive speech prosecutions therefore entered office with a public history inside the activist world of speech suppression, traced here.
Hermer exercised this power in high-profile matters; a parliamentary answer confirms that Hermer consented to Lucy Connolly’s prosecution under section 19 of the Public Order Act 1986 and handled 14 other applications between 9 and 14 August 2024, eleven within 24 hours. The Attorney General’s consent is supposed to restrain politically charged prosecutions; during the disorder it was exercised at conveyor-belt speed by a law officer publicly celebrated by Searchlight. Like so many features of the administration of Starmer – a close friend of Mr Hermer – this was an inversion of a safeguard which accelerated use of the full force of the law against the domestic population of Britain.
Makerfield & alleged election interference
McIntyre’s thread becomes more than a list of names when it deals with the Makerfield by-election; Josh Simons resigned the seat so that Burnham could return to Westminster, and on 15 May Independent Labour Publications carried Georgie Laming’s emergency appeal for Vote HOPE 2026 – a campaign fundraiser run by HNH. The money would pay for local organisers, targeted leaflets, digital advertising and data-led campaigning.
Vote HOPE recruited volunteers expressly to prevent Reform victories; the linked sign-up form bore the imprint of HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED, company number 08188502, and offered routes, materials and individual support. HNH also published material on Reform’s Makerfield candidate and people around his campaign. The political company was undertaking this work against Labour’s only serious challenger.

Fourteen candidates stood, but Wigan Council recorded 24,927 votes for Burnham and 15,696 for Reform’s Rob Kenyon, with every other candidate more than ten thousand votes behind Labour. HNH therefore did not need to print “vote Labour” on a leaflet; money, workers and targeted material directed against the only plausible rival supplied functional support to Burnham, and within weeks two HNH figures entered his Downing Street operation.
Farage complained first to the Charity Commission, alleging that HOPE UNLIMITED CHARITABLE TRUST had financed leaflets helping Burnham and opposing Reform. Guido published the complaint and Farage posted the letter on X, with both pointing to the scale of grants from trust to company and the Labour history of personnel in each body. HNH replied that the Makerfield money had been raised separately through the registered non-party campaigner and that charitable grants were ring-fenced.

The Charity Commission accepted that trust funds had not produced or distributed the leaflets. Farage then went to the Electoral Commission over donations, financial arrangements and campaign spending by HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED; HNH said it had remained within the limits, and no determination had been published by 24 August 2026.
HOPE NOT HATE LIMITED is entitled to campaign within electoral law, but registration as a non-party campaigner does not turn anti-Reform electioneering into neutral research or allow party-political campaigning to become the continuing purpose of a charity.
Nor was Makerfield an aberration, since the Daily Mirror partnership of 2009 and HNH’s own accounts of Dagenham and Rainham and Thurrock describe targeted leafleting, voter segmentation and defeating the BNP or UKIP as organised aims. HNH’s reports should be read with that electoral purpose in mind. Makerfield shows HNH’s usefulness to Labour in practice.
The antidote? A Freedom of Speech Act
The legal answer is to strip political dossiers of their institutional, regulatory and criminal force. The Freedom of Speech Bill published by the Adam Smith Institute, which I co-wrote with Preston Byrne and Elijah Granet, was drafted to achieve that purpose, disempowering both the censorial observer and the censor itself. It would limit punishment and process by public bodies, employers, professional regulators and essential service providers, curtail punitive non-crime speech records and restrict indirect state pressure on platforms. Lawful political expression would cease to be a professional death sentence merely because an activist publisher had attached a name and unflattering adjectives to it.


The Bill at no point discusses organisations such as HNH, nor should a bill founded on this principle need to do so; under its provisions, HNH may still investigate, criticise and name people where publication is lawful. The key change from today's situation is that an employer, regulator, covered bank or police force would have to justify the penalty it imposes as a result of such a smear, and the target would possess a statutory route of challenge which today is lost in a sea of ECHR-derived legal balancing acts which are not fit for purpose. Threats, fraud, harassment and violence would remain actionable; the political dossier would lose its ability to become an unofficial sentence. The wider case for the bill itself appears in a separate Reiners.org.uk article.
It has long been my view that platforms should also deal with the digital sin of doxxing before it is fed to the mob. A post clearly containing private identifying information could be quarantined from algorithmic distribution until a human reviewer has considered consent, purpose and malice. I covered the phenomenon of doxxing in both The Critic Magazine and Reiners.org.uk, for those curious about the appropriate way to mitigate this issue, one which is uniquely important for the Englishman living under Britain’s speech regime. At present, doxxing and defamation delight the algorithm while enforcement strolls in afterwards, if ever, by which time the name is loose and the damage done. X already recognises abusive intent in its policy; @Support should enforce the rule it has written.
Free to campaign, answerable for publication
Hope Not Hate is entitled to the same freedom it would deny many of its targets. The government should not ban it, the police should not visit its staff over harsh opinions and no employer should dismiss somebody merely for working there. If freedom of speech cannot protect Nick Lowles, it is not worth asking it to protect anybody less fashionable.
HNH earned genuine authority by investigating violent neo-Nazis and Islamist networks, then spent that authority on awkward councillors, private writers and anonymous broadcasters.
An organisation which keeps political case files on private people should state the rules by which it does so. HNH should explain when it will name a pseudonymous speaker, how it weighs public office and audience size, whether information may be bought, when relatives or neighbours may be approached, how long unused data is retained and how an error is corrected. Substantive amendments should remain visible, and the subject should receive the allegation, the evidence needed to answer it and a route to correction which does not begin with a five-figure legal bill.
The same plainness is required of charity and company, and every appeal, report and campaign should identify the legal body responsible while each grant document says what the money buys, who approved it and which restrictions apply. Government departments and public bodies which buy training, receive intelligence or consult HNH should identify the contracting entity, publish the scope and test the material for themselves.
People do not forfeit privacy and lawful speech because their opinions are ugly, eccentric or wrong. The targets discussed here face an organisation with money, access, lawyers and sympathetic press relationships; many have only a job, a home and relatives who never volunteered for public life.
Nothing here requires HNH’s abolition or a Conservative imitation. Let it become what its conduct reveals – an openly political publisher, funded and described as such, free to argue and answerable when its case is false. Its charitable partner may do genuine charitable work under its own name, while a Free Speech Act deprives this organisation's methodology of its unofficial jurisdiction over jobs, services and police records.